On my [Jim Szpajcher] recent visit to Virginia, I travelled for two days with a friend, who shares an interest in Civil War history. On a previous visit, in 2006, he and I had undertaken the drive to visit Gettysburg, the scene of the pivotal battle of the Civil War, which raged in Southern Pennsylvania in early July, 1863. This time around, we stayed in north-central Virginia, and our first stop was at Fredericksburg, roughly midway between Washington, D.C., and Richmond.
Some background -
By December, 1862, the Union forces were receiving vast amounts of supplies and men, while the Confederacy was running short on these basics, without which a war cannot be sustained. The main problem for the Union forces was that the leadership of the army had been lacklustre and hesitant. The main problem for the Confederate forces was that their supply lines had been disrupted as the Union army was occupying Northern Virginia, and the importation of vital goods had been blockaded by the Union Navy. The Army of the Potomac was flush, with 120,000 well equipped and well-trained men under the newly appointed Major General Ambrose E. Burnside, while the Army of Northern Virginia, commanded by General Robert E. Lee, struggled to field 78,000 poorly armed, poorly equipped men.

Bruce Catton’s "The Army of the Potomac", in Volume 2 "Glory Road", recalls an exchange between two pickets along the Rappahannock River in late November or early December, 1862:
"The whole army chuckled over the answer one brash Federal got when, observing that the Confederate on the opposite bank was exceedingly ragged, he called across to know if Rebels did not have any decent clothes. The Reb looked over at him for a minute, then called back: "We-uns don’t put on our good clothes to butcher hogs." (P.33)
On December 11th and 12th, Burnside’s forces bridged the Rappahannock River while under fire, and forced the Confederates out of Fredericksburg, which had been largely evacuated of civilians just before the battle started. Union forces, that night, vandalized and destroyed the town, which had long been an important trading center in Virginia, while Lee’s forces pulled back and shivered in positions on heights to the west and south.
On the morning if December 13th, Burnside’s plan was to strike the southern end of the Confederate positions, south of the town, while employing a smaller attack to the west out of the town as a diversion. The Union forces moved forward in late morning. During intense fighting, the attack on the south moved forward, then faltered, as there was confusion over following up an initial success against the Confederates.
In the meantime, the forces coming westward out of Fredericksburg, from the II Corps, commanded by General Darius N. Couch, did not have a clear path to advance - and Confederate soldiers had lined a road bed below a north-south ridge named after a local lawyer who lived there: John L. Marye (pronounced as "Marie"). Below Marye’s Heights, the main road between Washington and Richmond had been dug into the lowest slopes of the Heights, and lined with stone to shore up the sides. This stretch was known as the "Sunken Road", and was lined with thousands of Confederate soldiers, while on the heights behind the road, Confederate artillery was positioned to fire over the heads of the soldiers.
Between Fredericksburg and the Sunken Road were 600 yards of open ground, whose undulating surface concealed a canal, which could only be crossed by three small bridges - whose plank decking had been torn up from them. The Federal forces formed up to attack, and moved toward Marye’s Heights, only to find that they had to break up, cross the canal, and reform, before continuing to advance the final 400 yards to the Sunken Road, where General Longstreet had 4 ranks of riflemen waiting for them.

General William H. French was ordered to attack, and sent his three brigades forward in separate attacks, into blistering fire from the Confederate troops. The first attack went in at 11:30 in the morning. None of the attacks closed more than 100 yards from the road, and littered the open field with dead and wounded men. The survivors pulled back and went to ground.
General Winfield Scott Hancock had been ordered to follow French into action, and he formed up his men, sending his three brigades toward Marye’s Heights and the Confederate forces lining the Stone wall. Bruce Catton records Hancock’s Division attacking as:
The plain was covered with smoke, and men on each side saw the fighting only in glimpses, and what they saw was always the same. Up in front, in that last deadly zone between fifty and one hundred yards from the stone wall, one firing line would be crumbling and going to pieces under the fearful Confederate fire; farther back, while this was happening, the broad blue lines of a new brigade would be coming up into view on the high ground near the canal; and back by the town, compact columns would be marching down the parallel highways, making their way toward the canal. There never seemed to be any end to it, and the Confederates lost all track of the number of separate assaults they had repelled.
Units from the III, V and IX Corps were fed into the battle. General Howard’s Division went next, trying to skirt to the north, but the low terrain and a long slough, known as Gordon’s Marsh, forced his brigades back over in front of the Sunken road, to be devastated in succession.
General Sumner’s three brigades went forward, each failing in succession. While these rows of men were being scythed down, General Lee, watching from his position on the heights, turned to General Longstreet and is reported to have said: "It is well that war is so terrible. We should grow too fond of it."
By this time, about 3:30 in the afternoon, a comparative lull settled over the field. Towards 4 o’clock, General Hooker’s brigades started moving forward.
Shelby Foote wrote of this attack:
Down in the sunken road, Tom Cobb had been hit by a sharpshooter firing from the upper story of a house on the edge of town; he had bled to death by now; but his men were still there, reinforced by several regiments of North Carolinians from Ransom’s Reserve division. Shoulder to shoulder along the wall, they loosed their volleys, then stepped back to reload while the rank behind stepped up to fire. So it went, through all four ranks, until the first had reloaded and taken its place along the wall, which flamed continuously under a mounting bank of smoke as if the defenders were armed with automatic weapons. This attack, like the three preceding it, broke in blood. The Federals fell back, leaving the stretch of open ground between the swale and a hundred yards of the wall thick-strewn with corpses and writhing men whose cries could be heard above the diminishing clatter of musketry.
After sunset, General Andrew Humphreys, from V Corps, led an attack with two of his brigades of untried Pennsylvanians, ordering his men not to stop and fire volleys, but to fix bayonets and charge the Confederate positions.
Shelby Foote recorded:
From behind it [the wall], all this while, the rebels - many of whom were shoeless, without overcoats or blankets to protect them from the penetrating mid-December chill - taunted the warmly clad Federals coming toward them in a tangle-footed huddle after their encounter with the bog: "Come on, blue belly! Bring them boots and blankets! Bring them h’yar!" And they did bring them, up to within fifty yards of the flame-stitched wall at any rate. There the forward edge was frayed and broken, the survivors crawling or running to regain the protection of the swale, which by now they were convinced they should never have left.
In near total darkness, one brigade from IX Corps tried one last attempt to gain the Sunken Road. Bruce Catton records:
It was almost entirely dark when Rush Hawkin’s brigade from IX Corps made one final assault, coming up from the railway cut and swinging out into the open ground comparatively undamaged, and then getting the worst of it in one tremendous blast that seemed to shake whole regiments apart. The colonel of the 13th New Hampshire wrote that "with one startling crash, with one simultaneous sheet of fire and flame, they hurled on our advancing lines the whole terrible force of their infantry and artillery." Others who saw the charge said that the whole field lit up as if by sheet lightning when the Rebels opened fire. For a few moments, there was a wild melee as the broken lines swayed back and forth; some of the men unhurt by the rebel fire, were injured simply by being knocked down and tramped on in the unendurable confusion… Part of the brigade overlapped the left of the II Corps line and was shot by Federal bullets, and finally what was left of it sagged back into the shelter of the railway cut, and it was too dark to fight any more that day.
The Federals had lost 12,653 men, killed, wounded and missing, in the battle of Fredericksburg, with casualties averaging over 1,000 an hour in front of Marye’s Heights. Eighteen Brigades had charged in 7 major attacks to no avail. Confederate losses were documented at 4,201, a rate at which the South could not sustain. On the morning of December 16, the plain between Fredericksburg and Marye’s Heights was empty. The Union forces had retreated back across the Rappahannock.
Lee was angered at the vandalism that had been done to the town. And when a staff officer asked "What can we do?", while viewing the destruction of Fredericksburg, Stonewall Jackson replied, "Why, shoot them."
As the war progressed, however, the South could not find its feet, and no number of such battles could gain the recognition of independence that the Confederacy was fighting for. The long, grueling, slog continued on for another 2 years and 4 months, before grinding to a halt at Appomattox Court House, in April, 1865.
Over fifty years later, British and French generals would be trying to use tactics which had failed at Fredericksburg. On the first day of the Somme Offensive, July 1, 1916, the British General Haig, sent hundreds of thousands of men against the German machine guns, in human wave attacks as futile and valiant as those of the Army of the Potomac in December, 1862. At the Somme, however, the British Army’s casualties totaled over 59,000 in a single day - 19,000 killed, and over 40,000 wounded.
The old adage about history, and being doomed to repeat it, should have been studied more closely.
(by jim szpajcher)